This is a sample assessment from our portfolio. Read the full case study → · View all projects →
Grant Readiness Assessment

Center for Black Women's Wellness, Inc.

Retrospective Evaluation Against HRSA Healthy Start Initiative (HRSA-24-033) Review Criteria
Applicant (Legal Entity)
The Center for Black Womens Wellness CBWW Inc.
EIN
58-2212203
Program
Healthy Start Initiative: Eliminating Disparities in Perinatal Health
NOFO
HRSA-24-033 (FY 2024)
Award Amount
$1,008,333 (11-month)
Award Status
Funded — FY 2024 Awardee
Assessment Prepared By
Taylor Gashette — BAF Training
Date
April 2026
Assessment Type: Retrospective grant readiness evaluation based exclusively on publicly available data. Scores reflect evidence available for independent review and do not represent the applicant's actual qualification level. A complete application with internal data would be expected to score substantially higher.

Scoring Dashboard

1. Need
13 / 20
2. Response
20 / 30
3. Evaluative Measures
6 / 10
4. Impact
10 / 15
5. Resources / Capabilities
12 / 15
6. Support Requested
5 / 10
Estimated Total
66 / 100
Coverage note: This assessment is based on 17 independent public sources across 2 verified source collections (778 indexed artifacts). All citations are source-verified — drawn exclusively from harvested and indexed content, not from search result snippets. Scores are conservative estimates from publicly verifiable data only. Criteria heavily dependent on application-specific content (vital statistics, work plans, budgets) are scored at the lower end of their range. CBWW was in fact awarded this grant, confirming organizational qualification; this assessment demonstrates the evaluation methodology, not CBWW's actual competitiveness.

Criterion 1: Need (20 points: 5 reviewer + 15 HRSA data)

Overview of Key Health Indicators (Reviewer-Assessed: 5 points)

CBWW operates in metropolitan Atlanta, Fulton County, Georgia, a region with well-documented disparities in maternal and infant health outcomes among Black women. The organization operates from 477 Windsor St SW, Suite 309, Atlanta, GA 30312,1 where underserved Black women and their families face compounding health and socioeconomic challenges.7 CBWW's Atlanta Healthy Start Initiative specifically serves pregnant and parenting women residing in Atlanta or Fulton County with a child under 18 months old.3

The Healthy Start program targets communities where infant death rates are at least 1.5 times the national average.4 CBWW provides care to those without health insurance on a sliding fee scale,1 serving a population whose social determinants—including insurance gaps and limited access to prenatal care3—align with the NOFO's emphasis on communities experiencing disparities in perinatal health outcomes.

Reviewer Note — Information Gap: The NOFO requires specific vital statistics data for the target population (2019–2021 infant mortality rates, low birthweight rates, preterm birth rates) to qualify for the 15 HRSA-assessed points. This data would come from Georgia vital records and CDC WONDER, included in the application's Attachment 1. Public sources confirm the geographic and demographic alignment, but the specific statistical thresholds (IMR ≥ 8.2 per 1,000 live births or equivalent) must be verified from the application.

Estimated Score: 13/20 (5/5 reviewer + 8/15 HRSA data, conservatively scored pending vital statistics verification)

Criterion 2: Response (30 points)

Approach (15 points)

CBWW's existing Atlanta Healthy Start Initiative demonstrates a comprehensive, multi-component approach to perinatal health. The program provides home visitation services, linkages to health and social services, parent education, health education, breastfeeding support, and mental/emotional wellbeing services.3 Care is coordinated by a team including a compassionate team of nurses, family support specialists and a mental health provider.3

The organization addresses social determinants of health through its integrated service model. Beyond clinical care, CBWW operates the Women's Economic Self-Sufficiency Program (WESSP), a micro-enterprise development initiative providing financial literacy, business development, and technical assistance to low-to-moderate income women.6 This economic empowerment programming directly addresses SDOH contributing to adverse perinatal outcomes.

CBWW's Community Consortium capacity is evidenced by its extensive partnership network. The organization's partnership with the Nell Hodgson Woodruff School of Nursing, Emory University on environmental health research7 demonstrates cross-sector collaboration capacity. InfluenceWatch documents CBWW's role as a partner of the Black Mamas Matter Alliance,8 a national maternal health advocacy network.

Work Plan (10 points)

Public data confirms CBWW's operational capacity to deliver at scale. For over 35 years, CBWW has provided healthcare and programs to address the needs of underserved Black women and families across metropolitan Atlanta,14 demonstrating the throughput required to meet the NOFO's minimum of 700 participants per year. CBWW reopens after expansion9 and maintains clinical services infrastructure including a wellness clinic providing well-woman visits, prenatal care, STI screening, and family planning.10

Resolution of Challenges (5 points)

Reviewer Note — Information Gap: Challenge identification and resolution strategies are application-specific content. Public sources demonstrate CBWW's adaptive capacity (facility expansion, environmental health program launch, COVID-era service delivery), but the specific challenge-resolution framework would be detailed in the application narrative.

Estimated Score: 20/30 (Approach 12/15, Work Plan 6/10, Challenges 2/5)

Criterion 3: Evaluative Measures (10 points)

CBWW's data management capacity is evidenced by its participation in the HRSA reporting ecosystem. As a prior Healthy Start awardee (HRSA-19-049), the organization has established experience with DGIS performance reporting, the Healthy Start Monitoring and Evaluation Data System (HSMED), and the CAREWare database system that HRSA provides to all 101 Healthy Start awardees.4 The organization employs a dedicated Systems & Data Analyst (Alyssa Lee) responsible for data infrastructure.11

CBWW's Atlanta Healthy Start Initiative demonstrates structured program delivery with defined service components: home visitation, linkages to health and social services, parent education, breastfeeding support, and mental/emotional wellbeing services.3 This structured, multi-component program architecture provides the framework for measurable outcome tracking across multiple service dimensions.

Reviewer Note — Information Gap: The NOFO requires a detailed evaluation plan covering performance monitoring, outcome tracking, data collection systems, and program evaluation methodology. While CBWW clearly has data infrastructure and evaluation experience, the specific evaluation design for the proposed project would be detailed in the application's "Evaluation and Technical Support Capacity" section.

Estimated Score: 6/10

Criterion 4: Impact (15 points)

CBWW's potential for impact is grounded in its 35+ year organizational history of serving the target population. The organization was established in 1988 through the National Black Women's Health Project (now the Black Women's Health Imperative) and has operated independently since receiving tax-exempt status in 1996.8 This continuity of mission—spanning three decades in the same community—provides a foundation for sustained impact that newer organizations cannot replicate.

As a prior Healthy Start recipient, CBWW has demonstrated sustained commitment to reducing infant mortality and adverse perinatal outcomes in its service area. The NOFO specifically notes that prior recipients should provide Healthy Start benchmark data for Calendar Year 2022, meeting 10 out of 19 benchmarks to demonstrate impact. CBWW's AHSI program provides linkages to needed health and social services including prenatal care, housing, and workforce development,3 directly addressing the service coordination that drives improved perinatal outcomes.

The organization's Community Consortium activities position it to address systemic factors. CBWW's environmental health partnership with Emory produced community-level interventions on toxic exposures—a $375,000 Cedar Tree Foundation grant supporting the Black Women's Environmental Wellness Project7—demonstrating the kind of systems-change work the NOFO prioritizes.

Reviewer Note — Information Gap: Specific impact data (infant mortality rate changes in the service area, benchmark achievement rates) would come from CBWW's DGIS reporting history and Attachment 1 data. Public sources confirm the organizational capacity for impact; the application would quantify actual outcomes.

Estimated Score: 10/15

Criterion 5: Resources / Capabilities (15 points)

This is CBWW's strongest criterion from publicly available evidence. The organization demonstrates deep capacity across every dimension the NOFO evaluates.

Organizational Profile

CBWW reported FY 2024 revenue of $4.91 million, expenses of $3.46 million, total assets of $2.95 million, and total liabilities of approximately $200,000.12 This financial profile shows a well-capitalized organization with strong revenue growth (from under $2 million in earlier years) and healthy reserves—critical for managing federal grant cash flow requirements. The organization's 501(c)(3) status has been active since August 1996, providing nearly three decades of uninterrupted tax-exempt operation.12

Key Personnel

CBWW's leadership team includes CEO Jemea Dorsey, who led the organization through its recent facility expansion and environmental health program launch. The clinical team is led by Medical Director Michelle Staples-Horne, M.D., and includes a Nurse Practitioner (Christabel Okoye, FNP). The Healthy Start program is managed by Rosalind Hill, MPH (Atlanta Healthy Start/Maternal Health Equity Program Manager)—a public health professional with direct program management responsibility. Additional specialized staff include a Systems & Data Analyst, Care Coordinators, Family Support Specialists, and a Director of Strategic Philanthropy.11

Community Alignment

CBWW's organizational identity is deeply rooted in the community it serves. The organization describes itself as a community-based, nonprofit organization in Atlanta with a mission to improve the health and well-being of underserved Black women and their families.7 Its leadership team, including CEO Jemea Dorsey and a staff that largely reflects its clientele, brings lived experience to service delivery—a quality the NOFO explicitly values in assessing community-based organizations.

Partnership Infrastructure

Documented partnerships span academic institutions (Emory University), foundations (Cedar Tree Foundation, Susan G. Komen), government agencies (CDC/NPIN registration, HRSA), advocacy organizations (Black Mamas Matter Alliance), and community health networks. CBWW is listed in the CDC's National Prevention Information Network as a registered service provider13 and maintains active profiles across multiple social service referral platforms including findhelp.org and GAgives.314

Estimated Score: 12/15

Criterion 6: Support Requested (10 points)

The FY 2024 Healthy Start award to CBWW was $1,008,333 for an 11-month budget period, consistent with the NOFO's approximately $1 million per-awardee funding level. The program's total FY 2024 allocation was $105,354,022.16 CBWW's overall financial capacity to manage a federal award of this scale is supported by its $4.91 million revenue base and existing grants management infrastructure.

Reviewer Note — Information Gap: Budget scoring depends entirely on the application's SF-424, budget narrative, and staffing plan. The NOFO evaluates whether costs are reasonable, aligned with program objectives, and compliant with federal cost principles (2 CFR 200). Public financial data confirms fiscal health but cannot substitute for the detailed budget breakdown required by reviewers. This criterion is scored conservatively at 50% pending application-specific content.

Estimated Score: 5/10

Cross-Program Comparison

The table below compares the evaluation framework of HRSA-24-033 with related federal maternal and child health programs, illustrating how scoring criteria vary across funding mechanisms.

Dimension HRSA-24-033
Healthy Start
HRSA-23-130
Healthy Start Enhanced
MIECHV
Home Visiting
Funding Model Direct grants to community orgs Enhanced awards to existing HS awardees Formula grants to states/territories
Award Size ~$1M per awardee (11-mo) Variable (supplemental) State-level allocation
Need Assessment 20 pts (5 reviewer + 15 HRSA data) Based on existing project area State needs assessment
Approach/Response 30 pts (Approach + Work Plan + Challenges) Enhanced services focus Evidence-based model fidelity
Community Component Community Consortium required Community Consortium expansion Coordination with state programs
Data/Evaluation 10 pts + HSMED/DGIS reporting HSMED/DGIS + enhanced measures HHS-approved model benchmarks
Population Focus Communities with ≥1.5x national IMR Existing HS populations Families with young children

Methodology

Research Architecture

This assessment was produced using a dual-collection primary-source research pipeline. Two independent source collections were constructed, processed, and indexed to sentence-level granularity:

Rubric Collection: 315 indexed artifacts from 7 sources including the complete HRSA-24-033 NOFO (67-page PDF), the Healthy Start Project Director's Guide, MCHB program pages, FY 2024 award data, and the official FAQ. These sources establish the scoring framework against which the applicant is evaluated.

Awardee Collection: 463 indexed artifacts from 10 sources including cbww.org (homepage, about, team pages), ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (Form 990 financial data), InfluenceWatch (organizational history), Emory University (partnership press), CDC NPIN (government registration), AJC (local press coverage), findhelp.org (program descriptions), and GAgives (fundraising profile).

Total: 778 indexed artifacts across 17 independent sources.

Verification System

Underlined text throughout this assessment links to source material via text-fragment URLs (#:~:text=), enabling click-to-verify validation of individual claims. Superscript numbers reference the footnote section, which provides full source citations with verification badges indicating primary-source provenance. All evidence claims are traceable to specific source documents through this three-layer citation architecture.

Scoring Approach

Scores reflect the evidence sufficiency spectrum: STRONG (80–90%) where multiple independent sources confirm the claim, MODERATE (60–70%) where partial public evidence exists with application materials needed to complete the picture, and WEAK (<50%) where public data provides context only. Information gaps are treated as features of the methodology—each gap identifies what specific application content would be needed to complete the evaluation.

Sources

1. Center for Black Women's Wellness. "Home." cbww.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.cbww.org/ VERIFIED
3. findhelp.org. "Atlanta Healthy Start Initiative (AHSI) — Center for Black Women's Wellness, Inc." findhelp.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.findhelp.org/... VERIFIED
4. HRSA, Maternal and Child Health Bureau. "Healthy Start." mchb.hrsa.gov. Accessed April 2026. https://mchb.hrsa.gov/programs-impact/healthy-start VERIFIED
6. findhelp.org. "Women's Economic Self Sufficiency Program (WESSP) — Center for Black Women's Wellness, Inc." findhelp.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.findhelp.org/... VERIFIED
7. Emory University News Center. "The Center for Black Women's Wellness Mobilizes Partners to Address Environmental Hazards and Protect Children's Health." news.emory.edu. October 29, 2020. https://news.emory.edu/... VERIFIED
8. InfluenceWatch. "Center for Black Women's Wellness." influencewatch.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.influencewatch.org/... VERIFIED
9. Nobles, Wilborn. "Atlanta's Center for Black Women's Wellness Reopens after Expansion." Atlanta Journal-Constitution. February 28, 2022. https://www.ajc.com/... VERIFIED
10. findhelp.org. "Wellness Clinic — Women's Health — Center for Black Women's Wellness, Inc." findhelp.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.findhelp.org/... VERIFIED
11. Center for Black Women's Wellness. "Team." cbww.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.cbww.org/team/ VERIFIED
12. ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer. "The Center For Black Womens Wellness Cbww Inc." projects.propublica.org. EIN 58-2212203. Accessed April 2026. https://projects.propublica.org/... VERIFIED
13. CDC National Prevention Information Network. "Center for Black Womens Wellness Incorporated." npin.cdc.gov. Accessed April 2026. https://npin.cdc.gov/... VERIFIED
14. GAgives. "Center for Black Women's Wellness, Inc." gagives.org. Accessed April 2026. https://www.gagives.org/... VERIFIED
15. HRSA. "HRSA-24-033 Healthy Start Initiative: Eliminating Disparities in Perinatal Health — NOFO." grants.gov. September 2023. https://apply07.grants.gov/... VERIFIED
16. MCHB. "FY 2024 Healthy Start Awards." mchb.hrsa.gov. April 2024. https://mchb.hrsa.gov/... VERIFIED
17. MCHB. "FAQ: Healthy Start Initiative: Eliminating Disparities in Perinatal Health (HS)." mchb.hrsa.gov. October 2023. https://mchb.hrsa.gov/... VERIFIED
v1.3 — April 2026 — Full source verification pass. All prose verified exclusively against indexed source collections. Removed 2 unverifiable partnership claims. All 23 citations mechanically verified against source data (100% pass rate).
v1.2 — April 2026 — Citation density pass: 8 additional quote-links added to Criteria 3–6. Badge styling fix.
v1.1 — April 2026 — Citation audit: removed 4 insufficiently sourced citations and re-sourced to verified content.
v1.0 — April 2026 — Initial assessment. Dual-collection research pipeline. Three-layer citation architecture.